The Pros and Cons Of Birthright Citizenship – 13 Authentic Points + Tips

There might be affiliate links on this page, which means we get a small commission of anything you buy. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Please do your own research before making any online purchase.

The pros and cons of birthright citizenship are a hot issue for debate for policymakers. Why? Because most of them are in favor of birthright citizenship, and some are against it. Therefore, there is a clash of these supporters and non-supporters when they are to devise any policy. 

But like everything, birthright citizenship also comes with its benefits and disadvantages. It’s a mixed bag and that’s what we are going to do here; to shed light on all its pros and cons.

Definition of Birthright Citizenship:

Birthright citizenship is a legal process that allows individuals to receive national citizenship because of the location where they were born. It is a concept that is referred to as jus soli in the United States. It is applicable in a common-law manner.


13 Authentic Pros And Cons Of Birthright Citizenship

We are dividing the pros and cons of birthright citizenship into two sections. The first will discuss the advantages of the matter under discussion while the second section will discuss its disadvantages. 

7 Amazing Pros, Benefits & Advantages of Birthright Citizenship

1. Pros and Cons Of Birthright Citizenship – Improves Societal Diversity

One significant benefit among the pros and cons of birthright citizenship is that it improves societal diversity. A child’s life improves when he/she is born in a country with jus soli. How? Citizenship provides numerous benefits that cannot be accessed through a temporary visa or immigration.

A child with birthright citizenship is able t access all the amenities which The Government gives to the people. 

Birthright Citizenship Improves Cultural Diversity

2. Pros and Cons Of Birthright Citizenship – Security Of Children

The idea of birthright citizenship is to offer protection to youngsters who are born somewhere with questionable office work.

Newborns haven’t any control over the moves of their parents. Therefore, the act of birthright citizenship ensures that a infant could have a few level of country wide citizenship. 

Without birthright citizenship, a infant might be born someplace and have no legal citizenship in any respect. Therefore, the security of youngsters is one great pro of birthright citizenship!  

Birthright Citizenship Guarantees A Child’s Security

3. Reduces The Need For Social Services

Another significant pro of birthright citizenship is that it reduces the need for social services. How? For example, if a mother and father are non-citizens and their infant is born within the U.S. Then the social offerings will take the child and area in foster care. 

Social services carry out this procedure(s) because it creates a clean manner to reach out to the network. Also, Splits in immigrant households continue to be no greater, in particular in families which have recently immigrated. Why? Because there may be an “umbrella” of own family rights worried.

Therefore, birthright citizenship acts in favor of social services.

4. Eliminates The Idea Of A Caste System

Whereas each charter in the world preaches loyalty, humanity, and equality, it is not smooth to suggest these three in our routinely lives. But, birthright citizenship follows the footprints of equality.

There are not any socioeconomic circumstances related to this technique.  Without birthright citizenship, the societies will begin to shape caste structures and here is how”

At the top might be the natural citizens- getting all the blessings. In the middle are folks that can purchase citizenship.  At the lowest lie the immigrants- who do not have the proper to pursue citizenship.  Therefore, removing the caste system is one progressive pro among the pros and cons of birthright citizenship.  

benefits and dis benefits of birthright citizenship
Birthright Citizenship Promotes Equality

5. Encounters Political Unrest Around The Globe

Birthright citizenship permits the people to have an identity rather than being “stateless”.

Civil unrest and warfare are the defining elements of every state on our planet. The political turmoil and particular modifications in the policies make the people “stateless.” It means that the persons accumulate to no countrywide identification.  

Therefore, if a person has birthright citizenship, then he/she will own that identification no matter what happens. So there goes one other undeniable benefit of birthright citizenship. 

6. Pros And Cons Of Birthright Citizenship – Supports All Children

Another unique advantage among the pros and cons of birthright citizenship is that it supports all the children. It means that it will bestow citizenship on the children belonging to every class and race. 

If birthright citizenship cease to exist then the mother and father will have to go through numerous hassles.

For instance, the government might also require a birth certificate, national identity, or  few different shapes of evidence. It could additionally require the State to set up a machine of verifying new citizenship. This may want to inculcate a new registry or identification techniques, which would have an extra cost

Therefore, all the children enjoy the comfort of being under the one umbrella of birthright citizenship.

advantages and disadvantages of birthright citizenship
Supports Children Belonging To Any Race And Class

7. Pros And Cons Of Birthright Citizenship- Provides An Equal Standard

There are not any qualifications important for kids while birthright citizenship is present, and there’re no questions about ethnicity, culture, or status.

There are not any antecedents closer to being a citizen. This provides the opportunity for a child to escape from being a sufferer of the tradition or every other societal trait. Therefore, the most important perk of birthright citizenship is that it accepts you in manner who you’re. . 

6 Unfortunate Cons & Disadvantages of Birthright Citizenship

1. It Provides A Work Around Immigration Laws

If the child has birthright citizenship, he can easily sponsor the dad and mom who do not have that citizenship. In different phases, it will become less complicated for parents to enter the United States illegally. This creates a sequence migration manner, and with that, parents revel in all of the privileges. . 

Therefore the nonsupporters mark this as the biggest con of birthright citizenship.

2. Pros And Cons Of Birthright Citizenship- Benefits Manipulation

According to Senator David Vitter in 2015, a child is born in the U.S. every 93 seconds to parents who have questionable immigration status. Because that child is immediately a U.S citizen, the parents get the financial, social, and legal benefits. 

Therefore, With up to 400,000 newborns receiving birthright citizenship every year, there are millions of dollars in benefits that are given to parents. This affects the state treasury badly because this money could be used for a million other purposes. Therefore, the nonsupporters believe that birthright citizenship sucks out the state treasury and leaves no money for other vital issues. 

3. Gives The Chance To Break The Law

Birth tourism is an idea which happens in nations thatpossess  birthright citizenship rules. People may additionally plan to come back to a rustic, even on a legal visa, purely to have a child.

Once the child is born, they get citizenship, and they are able to go back home if they want to. Some may additionally try this for higher financial possibilities and a better lifestyle, but a few may accomplish that to cause disruption and damage to others. Therefore, birthright citizenship incurs the incentives to interrupt the law.

4. Pros And Cons Of Birthright Citizenship- Unmanageable Diversity

People from exclusive ethnicities and backgrounds have precise tales to share with the network. That is often what makes a country first-rate. However from time to time it gets challenging to manipulate and take care of one-of-a-kind races. 

Birthright citizenship probably dissuades the blessings of variety, and the world does not take into account a community as an entire. Therefore, this stands as a threat to the country wide identity and this stands as a vital threat among the pros and cons of birthright citizenship. 

5. It is Used For Crimes

Birthright citizenship isn’t always used within the manner it should be. With diversity, worldwide tiers of discrimination additionally pass high.

Also, minorities are on the downside due to birthright citizenship.  The intention of birthright citizenship’s legal guidelines is to ensure clean dwelling for coming generations. However it is in use for illegal immigration and different crimes. 

Therefore, birthright citizenship takes a wrong turn in its implication.  There’s no easy answer to the query of birthright citizenship. Some don’t forget it as discriminatory, even as others view it as an implementing image of existing laws.

By weighing the pros and cons of the subject, each use can come to the proper choice that works for a majority.

Illegal Immigration Becomes Common With Birthright Citizenship

6. 14th Amendment In U.S. Constitution Is No Longer Practical in Approach

Birthright citizenship isn’t always what creators of the charter wrote first of all. The 14th Amendment was created in July of 1868. The guys who documented it would have no idea what could show up a hundred and forty four years later.

Its authentic cause turned into to offer lately freed African Americans citizenship if they were born right here. At Present-day, this is a means for unlawful immigrants to sneak beyond the gadget and gain of citizenship.

Nonsupporters of birthright citizenship consider if they abolish this law, create a more truthful policy then, it might additionally resolve the controversy that the founders of the 14th Amendment couldn’t predict or foresee.

FAQ – Frequently Asked Question On The Pros and Cons Of Birthright Citizenship

What Are The Advantages Of Citizenship By Birth?

The advantage of birthright citizenship is that it may improve social diversity. When citizens know that their kids will be guaranteed a nationality if they are born in a nation with jus soli, then it is an easy way to improve that baby’s life.

Does It Make Sense To Give US Citizenship To All Babies Born In The United States?

In accordance with the provisions in the Fourteenth Amendment to the US Statute or constitution and the INA (Immigration and Nationality Act) U.S. nationality is automatically given to a person born within and subject to the authority of the United States which is known as jus soli.

What Does The 14th Amendment Say About Citizenship?

According to section 1, clause 1, of the Fourteenth Amendment, all people born or adopted in the US, and subject to the jurisdiction referred to in paragraph, are residents of the US and of the State wherein they live.

What Is The Hardest Citizenship To Get?

Vatican City With about 800 residents and 450 citizens, it is the smallest country in the world, maybe partially because it has one of the most difficult immigration policies in the world.

Conclusion: Where Does The Debate Of Birthright Citizenship Heads?

These birthright citizenship pros and cons are just the beginning of the conversation. Some see this concept as a vital issue of societal variety and inclusion. Some see birthright citizenship as a manner that creates a cash- take- hold for families who possess a protracted vision of circumventing immigration laws. 

Both aspects can point to real-lifestyles examples that aid their views in this difficulty. Nonetheless, there is a lot to do to enhance the modern-day state of affairs of birthright citizenship.

The government must work diligently to plan effective regulations that diminish the poor elements of birthright citizenship. Only then there could be a lift in socioeconomic, political, felony, civic, and judicial scenes of the nation. 

Further Readings:

For instance, birthright citizenship brings along a lot of travel restrictions. The government can work on this issue and ease those restrictions for good. Also, it will be great if the restrictions on obtaining a Visa to Russia are eased. 

Leave a Comment